Johnny's Pies

4.3 ( 178 reviews )
Checking... 04:00 AM - 08:00 PM See Hours
$10–20
32 N Main St, Medford, NJ 08055, United States
+1 640-600-4104

If you're searching for a culinary gem in Medford, NJ, look no further than Johnny's Pies. This charming eatery has quickly made a name for itself, thanks to its commitment to using organic, fresh ingredients and a rotating menu that keeps food enthusiasts excited. Customers rave about the gourmet pizzas, highlighting the unique flavors such as the sautéed mushroom pie and the buffalo chicken pizza, both praised for their perfect crust and taste balance.

Not just a pizza place, Johnny's offers a delightful array of salads, appetizers, and desserts that tantalize the taste buds. The peach pie and eggplant parm have emerged as standout favorites, while the garlic shrimp appetizer has become a must-try for many patrons. Reviews also highlight the warm and welcoming atmosphere, complemented by attentive service that contributes to an overall pleasant dining experience.

With limited seating that adds to its charm, be prepared for a slight wait, especially on weekends. However, as diners return time and again for the quality and consistency, it's clear that Johnny's Pies has rightfully earned its place as a local favorite. If you’re in the area, don’t miss the chance to indulge in their creative offerings—your taste buds will thank you!

Amenities and More

  • Service options
    • Takeaway
    • Dine-in
  • Popular for
    • Lunch
    • Dinner
    • Solo dining
  • Accessibility
    • Wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Wheelchair-accessible entrance
    • Wheelchair-accessible seating
    • Wheelchair-accessible toilet
  • Offerings
    • Comfort food
    • Quick bite
  • Dining options
    • Lunch
    • Dinner
    • Dessert
    • Seating
    • Table service
  • Amenities
    • Toilet
  • Atmosphere
    • Casual
  • Payments
    • Credit cards
    • Debit cards
    • NFC mobile payments
    • Credit cards
  • Children
    • Good for kids
    • High chairs
  • Parking
    • Free of charge street parking
    • Free parking lot
    • Parking
  • Pets
    • Dogs allowed outside

Reviews For Johnny's Pies

Dan Spataro
Jul 2,2025
This place is hands-down one of the best pizza spots around. They use organic, fresh ingredients, and you can taste the quality in every bite. I especially love that they’re always mixing things up—there are always new pies to try thanks to their rotating options. It’s clear they actually care about what they’re serving.
Rac Ba
Jun 8,2025
Amazing pizza, salads, desserts and apps! I’ve ordered from here multiple times and the food has yet to disappoint, and I don’t think it ever will. The peach pie was absolutely delicious along with their summer salad. The sausage and the mushroom pies are also out of this world. Eggplant parm app and all the dessert jars!! The pizza is gourmet and not your standard pizza place so I wouldn’t go here’s expecting a basic pie. If you want the pizza early for take out I would suggest ordering asap on the weekends even though to our family it’s always been worth the wait. We’ve only ever ran into a takeout issue once but it was resolved very kindly by I believe the owner which we greatly appreciated! Either way it wouldn’t have stopped us from ordering from here or dining in at the establishment. You can’t go wrong with Johnny’s pies!
#Hashtag SteveJ
May 21,2025
Stopped in again, always consistent always great!! Wow wow wow! We had the margarita pizza which has the olive oil on it that is so delicious. We also had the pepperoni which had honey and hot peppers for great extra taste! The crust is thin and crispy and the mild char around the edges is awesome. For extra deliciousness, get the garlic shrimp appetizer and hold on to the extra garlic sauce to dip your crust in! Thanks to Emily our waitress for not only suggesting that but for upselling us on everything including the unique yummy desserts. Service was awesome. Place is not huge and has limited tables so as the word gets out it will surely be harder to get in. Cool open pizza making area is the center of the place, so it is fun to watch them make all the delicious pies.
michelle gourley
Apr 29,2025
Went cause we heard good things about the place. We were in the area so we gave it a try. So glad we did. We ordered the jonnys salad and sausage and onion pie. The salad was perfectly dressed and could have eaten more it was so good. The pie had a nice amount of sausage. But what made it stand out was the cooked onion and the light and airy crust. It was a bright and cheerful Atmosphere so if your in the area, go try. You won't be disappointed. Looking forward to the next time we can try another salad and different pizza.
Lou
Apr 11,2025
Review of Johnny’s Pies – 9.3/10 I recently tried Johnny’s Pies, and let me tell you—it was outstanding. I ordered the mushroom pie and was blown away. The key? They saute the mushrooms first, which adds so much depth and flavor. The crust was exactly how it should be: crisp, perfectly baked, and held everything together without getting soggy. I also had the buffalo chicken pizza, and honestly, it’s the best I’ve ever had. Perfect balance of heat, flavor, and texture. These guys know what they’re doing. I wasn’t a big fan of the previous owners, but the new team is a total game-changer—warm, welcoming, and genuinely happy to serve. The service was on point and everything was ready on time. It’s clear they care. Overall, I give Johnny’s a solid 9.3 out of 10. If I had eaten it fresh in-house, it might’ve been a perfect 10. Highly recommend!
Steve G
Apr 3,2025
This is my second time coming here and I had an even better experience. Awesome pizza, great staff, amazing service. This place is a hidden gem. The pies are well done, perfectly, and only come in one size. They’re open Wednesday thru Saturday, from 4:00 to I think 8:00, make sure you find out hours before going. I got the pepperoni with peppers and a pepperoni with no peppers, both were awesome!
Dr Record
Mar 29,2025
10/10 pizza every time People are complaining about the burnt crust - Their pizzas are cooked well done; that's how they cook it, and it's delicious. I highly recommend it to anyone who likes good, high-quality pizza. No joke, I ate 2 pies in one sitting. (Buffalo chicken and pepperoni are to die for)
John Locke
Mar 6,2025
Best pizza this side of the Hudson River. Fresh ingredients, fun twists on traditional pies (the pepperoni with honey and jalepenos?? Mamma Mia!) and great overall atmosphere for the family or a BYOB date night. Once you have Johnny’s Pies everyone else’s in town just kind of tastes like a grocery story pizza. Whatever the secret is, they’re doing it right!

Add a Review

Quality
Location
Price
Space
Service

Location

Appreciated by Others

The Ancient Mariner
(182 review)
The Ancient Mariner
  • 451 Main St, Ridgefield, CT 06877, United States
Seafood restaurant
+1 203-438-4771
Blake's Cafe
(1357 review)
Blake's Cafe
  • 9216 FM725, McQueeney, TX 78123, United States
American restaurant
+1 830-557-6335
Luna Rossa
(193 review)
Luna Rossa
  • 347 E 85th St, New York, NY 10028, United States
italian restaurant
+1 212-517-3118
Sabor de Sanchez#2 Mi Colombia Bella
(257 review)
Sabor de Sanchez#2 Mi Colombia Bella
  • 18730 Tuscany Stone, San Antonio, TX 78258, United States
colombian restaurant
+1 726-300-5300
Dumplings Delight
(130 review)
Dumplings Delight
  • 516 E State St, Trenton, OH 45067, United States
Indian restaurant
+1 513-468-0135
Yum Yum Noodle Bar - RED HOOK
(333 review)
Yum Yum Noodle Bar - RED HOOK
  • 7496 S Broadway, Red Hook, NY 12571, United States
asian fusion restaurant
+1 845-835-6383
Chunky Chicken
(161 review)
Chunky Chicken
  • 789 Rochdale Rd, Harpurhey, Manchester M9 5XD, United Kingdom
Chicken restaurant
+44 161 277 9696
Minto Shawarma
(182 review)
Minto Shawarma
  • 405 Main St E, Palmerston, ON N0G 2P0, Canada
restaurant
+1 519-343-2300
PANCHITOS
(115 review)
PANCHITOS
  • 45 Spon End, Coventry CV1 3HG, United Kingdom
Takeout restaurant
+44 24 7667 4222
Fancy Fry
(147 review)
Fancy Fry
  • 9 Moulsham St, Chelmsford CM2 0HR, United Kingdom
restaurant
+44 1245 261025